Change Management for Distributed Ontologies
نویسندگان
چکیده
Preface A writer keeps surprising himself... he doesn't know what he is saying until he sees it on the page. It is often said that the preface is the most read part of a thesis. If this is true, what is the contribution of distributing a thesis to the progress of science? Why does NWO 1 pay for printing it? Let us first try to answer the question why the preface is thought to the most read part of a thesis. A possible answer is that the preface is the only part of thesis that is understandable for outsiders. If we assume that a preface normally doesn't describe the scientific contribution, this would be a bad sign for scientists about their ability to explain their achievements. However, I doubt whether this is the genuine reason. In this thesis, for example, the summary (page 181) is probably easier to understand than the preface with its numerous references to people that many the readers will not know. My hypothesis is that the preface is among the most read parts of a thesis because it gives a glimpse of the real process behind the nicely shaped-up story in the book. It hints about the moments of disappointment and desperateness, the time lost in mastering LaTeX, the writer-blocks, the procrastinating, the " essential " philosophical discussions with colleagues, and the oh-so-nice but not very relevant programming tasks. In the end, a preface shows that doing research is not the well-structured process that it seems to be, but that it is as humble as all other activities. It may very well be that this message is the essence of what scientists have to say to the world... Therefore, for the sake of science, continue reading the preface and don't feel obliged to read further. The research described in this thesis has been performed within the KIRMIT project. This thesis is probably not the outcome that the people who wrote the proposal for the KIRMIT project had in mind. When the project started, we expected to work with two PhD students on multimedia indexing and retrieval, but because of various reasons things went different. I would like to thank Bob Wielinga, Bert Bredeweg and Hans Akkermans for the freedom and the time they gave me to find my own way. Hans has been very inspiring during the whole process, with his clear ideas about research methodologies …
منابع مشابه
Agent-based Architecture for Service Ontology evolution management
Communication between services requires a common vocabulary to allow reliable exchange of information. However services are evolving independently and their ontologies evolve too. The existing distributed ontology evolution approaches are not scaled to dynamic environments like Semantic Web service architecture. As the distributed system grows in size, the complexity of ontology change manageme...
متن کاملAn Environment for Distributed Ontology Development Based on Dependency Management
This paper describes a system for supporting development of ontology in a distributed manner. By a distributed manner, we mean ontology is divided into several component ontologies, which are developed by different developers in a distributed environment. The target ontology is obtained by compiling the component ontologies. These component ontologies are identified according to their conceptua...
متن کاملManaging changes in distributed biomedical ontologies using hierarchical distributed graph transformation
The issue of ontology evolution and change management is inadequately addressed by available tools and algorithms, mostly due to the lack of suitable knowledge representation formalisms to deal with temporal abstract notations and the overreliance on human factors. Also most of the current approaches have been focused on changes within the internal structure of ontologies and interactions with ...
متن کاملSemversion: an Rdf-based Ontology Versioning System
Knowledge domains and their formal representations via ontologies are typically subject to change in practical applications. Additionally, engineering of ontologies often takes place in distributed settings where multiple independent users interact. Therefore, change management for ontologies becomes a crucial aspect for any kind of ontology management environment. This paper introduces a new R...
متن کاملA Framework for Knowledge Management in Distributed Collaborative Enterprise
In this paper we discuss the importance of ontologies in the knowledge management practices in the context of distributed enterprise, their maturation processes, the corresponding stages in their maturation, and the collaborative aspect of their creation. We then present our workflow and corresponding authoring tool architecture for the creation of semantic document, a sub concept in the ontolo...
متن کاملSemantic Versioning Manager: Integrating SemVersion in Protégé
Knowledge domains and their semantic representations via ontologies are typically subject to change in practical applications. Additionally, engineering of ontologies often takes place in distributed settings where multiple independent users interact. Therefore, change management for ontologies becomes a crucial aspect for any kind of ontology management environment. We introduce a new RDF-cent...
متن کامل